Joanne Smith

Marlin Travel
United Way
Framing & Art Center
Wesway
Coconut Bay
News
Click here to see more
Subscribe
Community Calendar
Click here for full listings.
Poll
Do you agree with Mayor Hobbs, that Kathleen Wynne owes the City an apology over the Thunder Bay Generating Station delays?



Total Votes: 79
View Results Past Polls

Market Research

Do you own your own home?
Who's Modo
User Submitted Photo Gallery
Submit Your Own Photos
2013-01-24 at 16:01

Protest a 'victory'

By Jeff Labine, tbnewswatch.com
Need Xtra Cash? Visit Xtra Cash!For payday advances and cheque cashing, there's no better option than XTRA CASH! Best rates, no holds, and instant Cash!Click here for full list of services

Attawapiskat’s acting chief calls Theresa Spence’s hunger strike a victory.

Christine Kataquapit said she felt relieved when she heard Spence was ending her protest. Spence started her solid-food hunger strike on Dec. 11 in order to have a meeting with Prime Minister Stephen Harper and the Governor General.

She had wanted to meet to discuss the poor living conditions many First Nation communities face.

After six weeks of forgoing solid food, Spence announced she would be stopping. She was taken to hospital and placed on an intravenous line.

Kataquapit said Thursday they are monitoring her health to make sure she’s doing alright.

“This morning she’s feeling a lot better,” Kataquapit said in a phone interview with tbnewswatch.com from Ottawa.

“She kept contacting our office and saying ‘I’m doing OK.’ I just wanted to support her and she wanted her community to pray for her. It is a victory. It took a woman to stand up and speak for the entire nation and even outside of the country. She was willing to die for her people.”

Spence became a central figure during the Idle No More movement. Kataquapit said Idle No More will continue even though Spence is ending her hunger strike.

The protest demanded the attention of Harper, his ministers and top officials but it also caused a divide among Canadians and those in other countries who wanted to see more help for Aboriginals and those who believed they already received too much.

The end of the solid food hunger strike came as other chiefs and politicians signed a 13-point declaration committing them to seeking immediate improvements to housing and education, a meeting of First Nations chiefs, the prime minister and Governor General and full implementation of treaty and aboriginal rights within five years.

Fort William First Nation chief Peter Collins said he hasn’t seen the declaration commitment yet but hopes to see the documents soon.

He also called Spence’s protest a victory.

“Her ending the strike has been something we’ve been looking forward to,” Collins said.

“There was a lot of pressure on her to give up the hunger strike. All the chiefs across the country, the prime minister and the country have gotten the message.”

Collins hopes the next step will be to discuss revenue sharing and implementing the treaties properly.

He said the 13 communities within the region will be meeting to discuss how the treaty will be implemented.


-- With files from the Canadian Press
 

Click here to submit a letter to the editor.
iCar

Click here to report a typo or error

Tbnewswatch.com(60)

Comments

We've improved our comment system.
Bigtime says:
Cannot wait to see all the comments NOT get posted....because those that disagree with her strike, or the whole movement are racist right?
1/24/2013 4:17:03 PM
TWM says:
How do you see comments when they're not posted??
1/25/2013 5:12:55 AM
Bigtime says:
*sigh* Yes, that is the joke you see...Thanks for coming out.
1/25/2013 11:33:22 AM
TWM says:
And that is my point exactly.. hate, disgust, loathing and laughing at are where many of these comments derive from. Thanks for admiting it was a joke though.
1/26/2013 9:31:50 AM
Doug Meyers says:
That fish broth must have been very high calorie!
1/24/2013 4:47:12 PM
razor_burn says:
Too bad she never started a hunger strike. Also, nobody wins in these situations therefore there is no victory. Just smoke and mirrors.
1/24/2013 4:52:28 PM
CM Punk says:
The fish broth is the same fat that is packed in cans that contain tuna.
She is fine. It was not a real hunger strike like she wants people to think.
Not to mention she went to a hotel every night according to news reports to "refresh" herself.
1/24/2013 4:52:59 PM
spazz says:
is there some sort of regulation for where you have to sleep when on a hunger strike? just curious.
1/24/2013 5:33:50 PM
ring of fire dude says:
Not to mention all the money from Attawapiskat's yearly budget went to pay for the Hotel , aircraft charter and her entourage . All that money could have been spent on building another home for a needy family in her community .
1/24/2013 7:08:01 PM
TWM says:
The focus was Bill C-45, not the "hunger strike"
1/25/2013 5:18:21 AM
sky high says:
I don't expect this to get posted but even though she actually gained weight during her hunger strike she is still the biggest loser.
1/24/2013 5:25:32 PM
TWM says:
The biggest losers are those that see the "hunger strike" as the main focus and not Bill C-45, the Omnibus Bill, these bills are legal but certainly not ethical. As members of a society, you'd think that would be important enough to address but people would rather comment on some silly little insignificant matter.
1/25/2013 5:25:12 AM
Random says:
Well my last post must have offended the selectively politically correct moderators here, but I'll try again.
When you go to the media stating you are going on a hunger strike to get your message out, and you in fact do NOT go on a hunger strike, it is SIGNIFICANT. No difference attacking people for focusing on the sham of a hunger strike then there is calling people racist for being critical of the criminal mismanagement of monies sent to some reserves.
Another attempt at putting a muzzle on people that you disagree with...either call them a racist, or refer to them as losers for mocking the "hunger strike", to make them too scared to voice an opinion.
The moderators here are just as guilty. No problem censoring what they think might offend one group, while not caring about others. Think they need to grow a pair.
I'll be surprised if this makes it.
1/25/2013 6:01:35 PM
drayton lad says:
Certainly not a glorious end if the choice is return to work or be fired! She was failing the ones she was elected to serve,so nothing has changed there either yet.The movement has 100% merit.She just tried to steal the limelight as the sacrificial lamb on something that started way before the heat was on her again. Only my opinion though so be easy on me and have a good day :-)
1/24/2013 5:39:34 PM
Sailsup says:
"Her ending the strike is something we've been looking forward to, Collins says"
Most intelligent thing ever uttered by Cheif Collins ever!
1/24/2013 5:44:24 PM
ranma says:
Look at before and after pictures of Spence, not much has changed. The real hunger striker was Robinson, who the media did not report on, because he decided to do it from his reserve, instead of spending millions to fly to Ottawa, have family held up in hotels, etc.

This was nothing more than a media grandstand by Spence, to keep the eyes away from the problems on her reserve. Why else would she tell the interm chief to arrest a Global news crew, if they did not get off the reserve??
1/24/2013 5:51:47 PM
Tiredofit says:
Ranma, do you send your white sheet out to be dry cleaned or do you do it in house? Is it hard to maintain the point in the hat? Do you starch it?
1/25/2013 8:33:57 PM
whatever1239 says:
So now can we get back to real news?
1/24/2013 5:59:24 PM
mercy mercy me says:
i have as much respect for her 'victory' as i do for Lance Armstrong's 7 'victory' yellow jerseys
1/24/2013 6:03:22 PM
unionbay880 says:
Lance Armstrong, what a fake. Probably was lying about being the first man on the moon too.
1/24/2013 9:23:07 PM
Someone411 says:
Facepalm!!...Neil Armstrong was the first man on the moon....
1/25/2013 9:53:45 AM
jb says:
wooooosh
1/25/2013 1:27:36 PM
moi says:
WHAAAAAT???

You really should get out of the house more often union..
1/26/2013 10:23:01 AM
michyj32 says:
Seriously? ...and after those comments we are supposed to respect your opinion?? Get out of the McDonald's drive thru window and read a damn book...what an embarrassment..my 6 yr old can make a more intelligent comment ..
1/26/2013 8:17:20 PM
damanisback says:
i once went two months on only beer and onion soup mix
1/24/2013 6:24:57 PM
Hey_Buddy says:
Doug Meyers...exactly! I certainly doubt it she was in any major health crisis.
1/24/2013 7:09:16 PM
Gord says:
Bigtime - let us know how you enjoy reading the postings not published. That was a great meaningless comment intended to breed nothing but racism. Congratulations, your point has been unfortunately taken.
1/24/2013 7:30:57 PM
Bigtime says:
259 Agrees in 24 hours can't be wrong Gord. But I am curious as to how this Breeds racism? I was merely making a pun towards the fact the so many comments on this issue getting taken down, glad you did not get the joke but thats ok maybe next time I will write in crayon for you. Please explain to me, how exactly my comment breeds racism, there is not a a single racist remark on here and its sick and pathetic of you and others to state that there is. Are you telling me, that because people either did not agree with her hunger strike, did not agree that it is a victory, or believe that she is a fake or a fraud...that this by the very definition is racism? Your absolutely clueless, there is a lot of people that did not support her "liquid diet" (I will no longer refer to it as a Hunger strike) or the entire movement for a variety of reasons, so by your logic, if we do not support or agree, its racist? Lovely scare tactic to gain support. Go back to your Archie comics.
1/25/2013 11:43:57 AM
Gord says:
wow, time to get a handle on that agression. You obviously have some rage issues - perhaps I touced a nerve or maybe you are just angry and frustrated with your life in general. Either way, take care of yourself and lay off the caffeine. But, before I go - the number of people tha tagree with a comment doesnt make it right, you should know better than that. It is interesting you choose to think Im stupid - i think you would have to chuckle over that if you actually knew me. Anyway, no point discussing this further with you - enjoy your frustrating and rage filled life.
1/25/2013 4:02:13 PM
Bigtime says:
Well actually Gord, we do live in a democracy where majority rules...soooo the more people that agree, actually does matter. So you are right, I will have to chuckle over your idiocy without having met you.
1/26/2013 10:20:17 AM
crankypants says:
I'm just wondering... Who she feels is responsible for the "poor living conditions on her reserve" ? Certainly not herself or the ppl who live there...
1/24/2013 7:40:16 PM
glass half full says:
Chief Spence, You are a hero, you did an amazing thing, Chief Spence when I grow up I want to be like you.

Chief Spence you have given such hope to ALL of Canada.

I pray you are healthy and strong and that this horrible hunger strike didnt cause you and lasting effect on your well being.

Chief Spence, your HONESTY and your ACCOUNTING skills should be set as a bench mark for the rest of Canada to follow. Chief Spence will you please educate the rest of Canada how 2+2=6. Your Gaundi like crusade was simply inspiring to me and my family.

When your people compared you to Mother Mary during an interview, they were correct. You are a walking saint in my books.

Again I want to thank you and please know> if you ever need me to throw my jacket over a mud puddle so you can walk over it. I will be more than happy to use it on your behalf.

(TBSOURCE IS THIS ENOUGH SUPPORT TO GET POSTED ON YOUR SITE)
1/24/2013 7:43:10 PM
silverado92 says:
Only person I have ever seen grow another chin on a hunger strike....
1/24/2013 7:55:32 PM
Baor says:
This was not a hunger strike. If it was any layman would be able to look at her and see. A 44day hunger strike would have landed her in the hospital much longer than a few hours
She was "willing to die for her people" ....puleeez! This from a woman who drives an Escalade while her people live in leaky shacks.
Bitching about the government while squandering millions of tax payers money while they also paid for her 44 day publicity stunt AND her trip to the hospital for "treatment" makes me so angry. Angry at her....not her people or the government.
This was a success at showing how to distract your people from the fact that you can live like a queen while blowing money supposed to help them. Perhaps now she will allow the media back on her reserve to photograph her house.
Otherwise I hope we never hear from this disgrace again . In fact she can go into the dustbin of history like the "occupy" movement did last year.
1/24/2013 8:22:18 PM
downtownie says:
Chief Spence is not the voice of reason or a great speaker. Her speech sounded like a bad thankyou speech at a wedding shag at some hall. Speaking is not one of her strengths.
1/24/2013 8:23:13 PM
Spartan says:
Now that the circus show has left, I hope they clean up their mess on that little island, You know, "practice what you preach". They say its their land hopefully they will clean it up. Unfortunately, the tax payer will foot the clean up bill, nothing new there.
Chief Spence, you are a fraud and a disgrace to your people and reserve, shame on you.
1/24/2013 9:20:25 PM
myspace_ says:
A hunger srike/liquid only strike is not any way to get things accomplished, to think that this is the best way to help your community is ridiculous and shows with out a doubt that Ms. Spence is not a leader, she has accompished nothing, and has not helped her community at all.....just a waste of time, waste of money, waste of newspaper space.....
1/24/2013 10:45:37 PM
barry medawin says:
Now let's step this up a notch with more blockades and perhaps some help from our brother in the Guy Fawkes masks. Don't let up brothers and sisters!

Standing around watching does nothing!
Simplyobserved = lame duck.

it's time to stand up and be counted!
1/24/2013 11:25:28 PM
Meta says:
Barry rather than preaching hate and promoting energies that do not help our people. Like Theresa and her show to hide thefactthat the community moneys were squandered .

Get out and go help your ashnibek brothers and sisters , rather than preach anger and hate. Our own efforts not the help or the pouring of money will help our people. Too many first nation people have given into the fix my problem mentality rather than doing it them selves. We were a great independent people oncebeforeandcan be again if we fix ourselves first
1/25/2013 7:55:32 AM
thunderbay04 says:
I'm so suprised that users are able to comment on this artical. That being said I am relieved that money can now stop going towards covering this carnival of a fake hunger strike. I dont know why its considered a victory...she got her meeting and then ducked out. What a joke.
1/25/2013 12:00:40 AM
Tbay99 says:
What I found most appalling about this whole Spence debacle was that people actually had the nerve to try and compare her with Ghandi.
1/25/2013 12:12:11 AM
johnboy says:
Spence deserves this years Academy award if nothing else.
I didn't know a "liquid diet" included GRAVY!
1/25/2013 4:54:39 AM
grazzroots says:
Well she tried to pull the wool over her followers eyes,unfortunately it was 90
percent cotton
1/25/2013 6:43:21 AM
TWM says:
Racism and prejudice are against the law but hate, loathing, disgust, resentment and laughing at.. are not.
1/25/2013 6:57:11 AM
Watchmaker says:
What kind of victory is it when the purpose of her hunger strike (meeting with the PM and GG) were not met. The PM is NOT interested in real dialogue with FN's, nor is he interested in solving any of the social-economic issues inherent in the Reserve system. On the other side of the coin, FN's need to become part of the solutions and recognize that change needs to come from within as well as without.
1/25/2013 7:33:47 AM
vimeo says:
They gave in becuase they we were tired of hearing this on the news everyday. Hunger strikes are so yesterday.
Next the feds will be blamed for her ailing health for doing this strike.
1/25/2013 8:23:34 AM
pub27 says:
"unionbay880 says:
Lance Armstrong, what a fake. Probably was lying about being the first man on the moon too."

Please tell me your not serious about this statement....
1/25/2013 8:38:13 AM
Tj says:
I'm reading all these comments and I'm so embarrassed to say I'm from Thunder Bay. Take a look at these comments, she stood up for something she believed in to make a point to the government that there needs change. And if you don't think that aboriginals need change for the better, you should read up, and understand what is really going on, this is a city with a mass amount of indegeous people, instead of being racist towards them, not standing with them, embrace the beautiful culture your lucky to have around you.
1/25/2013 8:53:03 AM
Tbay99 says:
She also mismanaged her reserve into a crisis state and blamed the government/taxpayer, like many FN do. If I mismanage my funds and go on a 'hunger strike' will people stand with me and eventually give me more money? No they wouldn't! Calling people racist every chance you get is growing old, it's the lowest, most pathetic attack when you have no cards left to play.
1/25/2013 12:39:03 PM
Tannoy says:
Blocking roads and rails to raise awareness for your cause is not the way to go, you dont think that the second you delay someone your not just causing animosity and anger you need to give your head a shake. Inconvenience people and they will be against your cause. Nobody in their right mind is going to say "wow im late for work now but jeez i should really get onboard with this".
1/25/2013 8:54:46 AM
thecity says:
Many comments here just illustrate the deep rooted racism that goes on in Canada today. Also the ignorance, do the tiniest bit of research people, open your eyes. These are our fellow citizens taking a stand, we should all be proud, and be supportive, stand with our Canadian brothers and sisters, our friends and neighbours.
1/25/2013 9:01:49 AM
emma171 says:
Ah, the racism card. People on this site always criticize city council, our government, etc. when they disagree with a decision, the squandering of money, etc. But now we criticize Chief Spence, who is at best extremely incompetent (no record keeping) and possibly a thief who misappropriates government money intended to help her poeple, and we are racist.

Unfortunately, this is the attitude of so many of the chiefs who always want more, but don't want to be accountable because wanting accountability is somehow racist.
1/25/2013 11:59:32 AM
Tom Sanderson says:
I don't believe it is all racism. In my opinion I think people are more peeved that there is a huge waste of money on reserves and no accountability. The biggest beef the indians have with bill c45 is the proposed changes to the indian act. Many of the northern reserves have absolutely no economic value to contribute to the existence of their residents.
My best friends are indian and they are disgusted with the way the INM moment was conducted in regards to the rail and highway blockades. Now that the drama Queen has stopped her fast, and is suppose to be going back to her job, the government can do an audit and find out why she didn't address the deplorable conditions her band member endure.
1/25/2013 12:18:40 PM
barry medawin says:
That's never gonna happen! This is why IdleNoMore needs to step it up a notch. Stop asking for respect and take it brothers and sisters!
1/25/2013 2:43:01 PM
Mazda323 says:
Meta, your comment was one of the best I've seen on this site.
Given the three ring circus that Spence was just the ringleader of, I don't blame the Prime Minister for not wanting to meet with her.
If there are going to be solutions, they need to be brought to the table by the chiefs who are honest, educated and willing to work toward a goal that benefits everyone, rather than just demanding they get what they want and throwing a temper tantrum like a small child when they don't get it
1/25/2013 12:25:18 PM
thatsright says:
how these uneducated, misinformed comments breed so much hatred for a cause and group of people that have remained calm, peaceful, patient and understanding. before you comment, ask yourself, why build a fence that divides? is your right to equality, justice and sustainable life not important to you? because that's what spence and the idle no more protests are all about. nothing more, nothing less.

"I won't fight you, but I will get educated. Honour the old ways and walk the good path. I won't fight you but I will overcome your fear with deep compassion".
1/25/2013 12:58:47 PM
Mazda323 says:
Pub27 - what's even scarier than unionbay880's post is that seven people agreed with them!
1/25/2013 1:32:12 PM
JET says:
People protest everyday, you may have your reasoning for supporting or not supporting their cause, that is your constitutional right. however, resorting to name calling and stereotyping, that is blatant ignorance. Perhaps more time should be spent becoming educated on the issues and less time squandered with non-sensical rhetoric, these comments spawn a negative response, that is often race related. I am a person of First Nation heritage and proud of it!, let's face fact, these issues will continue to plague us for many moons to come. I respect the opininons of both sides of the arguement, however more validity is gained, when your comments or opinions are stated in a manner that is educated an non-confrontational. Have a great weekend, stay safe!
1/25/2013 2:31:56 PM
someone411 says:
I completely agree with you JET. But we also shouldn't be called racist just because we disagree with you. I'm all for equality and I believe Chief Spence should be audited and scrutinized just like anyone else would!
1/25/2013 4:16:12 PM
tiredofit says:
I dont know how people can say we aren't that racist in this town is beyond me, I sit here and read all of these comments it's very clear we are a very racist city and apparently most of them hang out here when not attending their regular "group meeting"

Are First Nations perfect? No, however take a good hard look at the rest of society and you'll see they aren't so perfect either! However we don't sit here and point it out and blame the entire society for it do we. First Nations have a unique set of challenges, the biggest is the rest of society that groups them all together and labels them various things. Guess what folks, their human beings and society as a whole has treated them like second class citizens, I see it daily, be it here, on the streets in the media etc.... Put yourself in their shoes for a minute.. Seriously, I challenge to you all to do it.

1/27/2013 11:07:06 AM
Comments for this story are semi-moderated. Read our comment guideline.

Add a new comment.
You must log in to add comments.
Create a new account
Forgot password?
Log In
 
 
© 2013 Dougall Media.