Skip to content

Thunder Bay makes the Top 10 list of worst cities for driving

The report is based on at-fault collision and traffic ticket history.

THUNDER BAY — Thunder Bay drivers earned just a "C" in a report card that compares driving records of motorists across Ontario. assigned the grades on the increased–or decreased–likelihood of drivers in each community being responsible for a collision or getting a traffic ticket.

Using information supplied by drivers seeking motor vehicle insurance quotes in 2018 and 2019, the company calculated the average for drivers' records in three categories: at-fault collisions, tickets, or both.

These are infractions and collisions that drivers admitted responsibility for, but which could have occurred in their home community or anywhere else they have driven.

Based on this data, listed the 10 worst cities in Ontario for driving, and assigned a letter grade as follows:

  • Orangeville  D
  • Bradford  D
  • Woodstock  D
  • Sault Ste. Marie  D
  • Orillia  D
  • Thunder Bay  C
  • St. Thomas  C
  • Caledon  C
  • Barrie  C

The 10 best cities for driving, which received an "A",  were Toronto and nine other communities in the Greater Toronto Area.

For a centre to be included in the study, insurance quotes had to be requested by at least 1,000 local drivers. says that, on average, 3.5 per cent of Ontario drivers, and 6.3 per cent of Thunder Bay drivers, have both a collision and a ticket on their records.

It says 6.9 per cent of Ontario drivers and 10.9 per cent of Thunder Bay drivers have received a ticket in the last three years.

"A driving record is a significant factor in determining insurance premiums," said company spokesperson Anne Marie Thomas.

"Even one collision or ticket on your record can increase premiums by as much as five per cent for one minor ticket and 30 per cent for one accident," Thomas said.

According to, at-fault accidents stay on your record for insurance purposes for at least six years, and traffic ticket convictions affect insurance rates for at least three years.



push icon
Be the first to read breaking stories. Enable push notifications on your device. Disable anytime.
No thanks